Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Michael Faulkner's avatar

I am concerned about your note "If you are tired of capitalism...". You may know more about Berry's political vision then I do, but from what I understand he does not call for the end of private property or enterprise. His economic critique is rather on abstraction and the elimination of community-based economies that are properly scaled and placed. And you touch on this and the consumptive economy in that note. But I am worried that you are putting Berry in a box of left leaning politics when his political vision is much more complicated then that - I don't want any political side to co-opt Berry and his ideas.

I also do not like that we have to frame everything we do in relation to politics. Berry doesn't just call us to resist the system, he calls us to a higher moral vision of humanity - he gives us substance to what it means to be good. It grieves me that we are no longer able to appeal to arguments of doing and being simply based on the goodness of those tasks.

Anyways, I really am just a new fan boy of Berry. And I enjoyed this essay, so thank you.

Neela's avatar

As a student of Indian philosophy, this push pull between showing up on Main St and retreating into a garden of ones own is inescapable. We grew up listening to our mothers says "didnt make you bed in the morning, but will go out into the world to achieve good huh". buddhism encouraged individuals to retreat and work upon themselves first. Krishna in the Gita asks capable individuals to show up on the battlefield and not draw a circle around themselves to implode into. The balance between, is what I hope the future history books show us when they analyze progress/regression.

14 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?